Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

True love waits. In high school, Cary, Shiloh, and Mikey were a tightknit trio of quirky kids. Cary and Shiloh loved each other deeply but could never admit it, even to themselves. When they reconnect in their 30s thanks to Mikey, lots of things have changed, and some have not. Cary is still in the Navy—his high school ROTC training and destiny to leave Omaha was something Shiloh hated in high school. He’s stationed in California and spends months at sea. Shiloh is still in Omaha. She has two wonderful children and a jerk of an ex-husband and hasn’t done anything with her life that she thought she would. Both of them are smart, clever, misanthropic, and stubborn. They are also, along with the omniscient narrative voice and tertiary characters, very funny. Rowell does longing like nobody’s business. She pits epic love against relatable, painful foibles. Cary and Shiloh want each other palpably, but they get hung up on little details, feel shame, project, overthink. They struggle mightily to believe they’re lovable. And they aren’t rolling in privilege, having many practical limitations besides her kids and his career: Shiloh has no family other than her mom and can’t afford to travel; Cary has a mother in poor health and a lot of family that can’t help. Just as the things that keep Shiloh and Cary apart are rooted in real-life problems, the things that might bring them together are quotidian and harder to accomplish than any grand gesture: Hope. Communication. Grief and trust. Chapters that dip back in time play to Rowell’s strength writing the confused passions of teenagers and show just how long these two have been absolutely gone for each other. Readers will be desperate to see them work it out. A treat for fans of Rowell and of realistic romance. Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.