Reviews for The Pioneers

by David McCullough

Choice
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.

McCullough’s book offers an old-fashioned narrative of the settlement of the Northwest Territory in the period of the Early Republic. It focuses on prominent New Englanders involved in the founding of Marietta, Ohio, including Rufus Putnam, Manasseh Cutler, Ephraim Cutler, and Samuel Hildreth. Marietta is depicted convincingly as a locus of national historical developments such as the Northwest Ordinance and the Burr conspiracy. The book becomes increasingly hagiographic as McCullough follows the life stories of his protagonists up to the Civil War years. He frequently extols the virtues of his New England transplants, their hardihood, foresight, public-spiritedness, devotion to education, and opposition to slavery. But as history, McCullough’s account suffers from his failure to consider the lives and viewpoints of the Native Americans who already resided in the region. Indians are portrayed merely as a sinister, treacherous problem that must be overcome by the harbingers of civilization. Historians such as Susan Sleeper-Smith (CH, Jul'02, 39-6650), (CH, Aug'15, 52-6591) have explored the Indigenous world of the Ohio River Valley with much greater accuracy, complexity, and nuance. Summing Up: Not recommended. --Robert L. Dorman, Oklahoma City University


Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Pulitzer Prize winner McCullough (Wright Brothers) illuminates the lives of early settlers into the Ohio country. The Northwest Territory was acquired from Britain following the American Revolution; the seed of the future Great Lakes states of Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, and Wisconsin. McCullough highlights that this region was founded as free-soil territory, a refreshingly positive spin on American history. The story centers on the settling of Marietta, OH, while also touching on developments in other parts of the region. The text presents the hardships of pioneer life, including the daily labors, the dangers of childbirth, and tensions with Native Americans. The work concludes in the mid-19th century. In many ways, one can see this as a continuation of McCullough's 1776, with the young United States now hatching into a large civilization whose ideals migrated west with the settlers. The author's gift for telling history as a story through the lives of those who lived it will engage even casual readers, who will enjoy the accessible style and gentle pace. VERDICT A must-read for American history buffs, produced by one of today's greatest scholars. [See Prepub Alert, 11/5/18.]-Jeffrey Meyer, Mt. Pleasant P.L., IA © Copyright 2019. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.


Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.

Drawing on little-known archives, acclaimed popular historian McCullough offers a unique chronicle of the settlement of the Ohio River Valley that emphasizes the courage and tenacity of early pioneers and the precedents they set for further westward expansion. The Northwest Territory was the howling wilderness that extended northwest from Virginia as far as Minnesota, and it was forbidding country, though the land was fertile, luring settlers down the Ohio River. Among them were Manasseh Cutler, a high-energy polymath preacher and botanist whose lobbying secured key congressional support for the pioneers; his son Ephraim, Federalist legislator and educational advocate involved in the founding of the region's first university and an early library system; and Rufus Putnam, the general who led a group of Revolutionary War veterans to found the New England-inspired town of Marietta on the banks of the Muskingum. Their stories form the backbone of McCullough's narrative, though he is equally fascinated by less prominent settlers, who demonstrated remarkable grit under extremely adverse circumstances. This is a compact work, but it often feels epic. And Pittsburgh-born McCullough's personal affection for the region abounds.HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Best-selling McCullough's latest vivid take on American history will generate avid interest.--Brendan Driscoll Copyright 2019 Booklist


Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

A lively history of the Ohio River region in the years between the Revolution and the Civil War.McCullough (The American Spirit: Who We Are and What We Stand For, 2015, etc.) isn't writing about the sodbusters and hardscrabblers of the Far West, the people whom the word "pioneers" evokes, but instead their predecessors of generations past who crossed the Appalachians and settled in the fertile country along and north of the Ohio River. Manasseh Cutler, one of his principal figures, "endowed with boundless intellectual curiosity," anticipated the movement of his compatriots across the mountains well before the war had ended, advocating for the Northwest Ordinance to secure a region that, in McCullough's words, "was designed to guarantee what would one day be known as the American way of life"a place in which slavery was forbidden and public education and religious freedom would be emphasized. "Ohio fever" spread throughout a New England crippled, after the war, by economic depression, but Southerners also moved west, fomenting the conditions that would, at the end of McCullough's vivid narrative, end in regional war three generations later. Characteristically, the author suggests major historical themes without ever arguing them as such. For example, he acknowledges the iniquities of the slave economy simply by contrasting the conditions along the Ohio between the backwaters of Kentucky and the sprightly city of Cincinnati, speaking through such figures as Charles Dickens. Indeed, his narrative abounds with well-recognized figures in American historyJohn Quincy Adams, Harriet Beecher Stowe, Johnny Appleseedwhile highlighting lesser-known players. His account of Aaron Burrwho conspired to overthrow the government of Mexico (and, later, his own country) after killing Alexander Hamilton, recruiting confederates in the Ohio River countryis alone worth the price of admission. There are many other fine moments, as well, including a brief account of the generosity that one farmer in Marietta, Ohio, showed to his starving neighbors and another charting the fortunes of the early Whigs in opposing the "anti-intellectual attitude of the Andrew Jackson administration."Vintage McCullough and a book that students of American history will find captivating. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.