Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.

The Bodie Island Lighthouse Library has become a construction site, thanks to the aging foundation. A few days before the historical society's planned Settler's Day Fair, celebrating Outer Banks history, Lucy Richardson and her boss, librarian Bertie James, are called to the construction site to oversee the removal of a Civil War strongbox. Opening it, they find a journal containing a hand-drawn map and what looks like a code. They lock it away in Bertie's desk, but rumors of buried treasure spread through the small town, bringing members of the historical society and historians from the local college to the library. That night, Lucy, who lives in an apartment above the library, is returning after dinner with her beau when they find the library door bashed in, Bertie's office ransacked, historical society president Jeffrey Hughes murdered, and the map and code sheet missing. In the run-up to the fair, Lucy learns that many have reason to want Hughes dead and launches an investigation. As with Gates' The Spook in the Stacks (2018), this is a sure bet for library-loving cozy readers.--Karen Muller Copyright 2010 Booklist

Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

In Gates’s delightful sixth Lighthouse Library mystery (after Something Read, Something Dead), workmen who are excavating around the foundations of the lighthouse in Nags Head, N.C., discover a tin box containing a leather-bound diary dating from the Civil War era, along with a couple of loose sheets of paper and a mysterious map of the Outer Banks. The find has the entire town dreaming of buried treasure. Within minutes, librarian Lucy Richardson and the library staff are fending off squabbling scholars and members of the local historical society. An exasperated Bertie James, the library director, orders the historians to leave and locks the box in her desk for the night. After dinner, Lucy returns to find the front door open, the map gone, and a man lying dead on the floor of Bertie’s office. Gates provides loads of eccentric and amusing suspects, shifting motives for the theft and for the murder, and a surprising solution to the mystery contained in the map. Cozy fans looking for good, fast-paced fun will be rewarded. Agent: Kim Lionetti, BookEnds Literary. (Oct.)

Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

The Outer Banks of North Carolina offer stunning beaches, historical sites, and murderers.Librarian Lucy Richardson is delighted that her community has raised the large sum of money needed to save the lighthouse that houses the library and her apartment (Something Read, Something Dead, 2019). But a metal box found buried near the wall proves to be a harbinger of trouble. The box contains a small leather-bound notebook, a hand-drawn map with some numbers, and what appears to be a cypher that proves difficult to crack. Although the journal records nothing more gripping than notes on the daily weather, the whole trove draws the interest of many people with their own nefarious reasons, and a tale of buried treasure quickly spreads. Members of the library board and two ambitious college professors fight over the find, whose notebook was written by a Mrs. Crawbingham, a name unknown to even the island's keenest historians. When Lucy returns from dinner with her boyfriend, mayor and dentist Connor McNeil, they find the library door smashed and historical society member Jeremy Hughes dead in the room where the box was locked away. The notebook is still there, but the map and code page are gone, though not the photographs of them Lucy had the wit to take. Police detective Sam Watson, no stranger to Lucy's skills as a sleuth, is willing to cut her some slack while she investigates while warning her of possible danger. Jeremy, who had a bad reputation with women, was having yet another affair and claiming he was about to get a divorce from a wife he's left less than brokenhearted. He was also involved in enough dubious business deals to create plenty of motives for his death. Cracking the tricky code looks to be the key to the case.Historical injustices combine with a touch of romance and code-breaking in a neatly packaged cozy. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.