Reviews for This land is our land : how we lost the right to roam and how to take it back
Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.
Throughout history, our ancestors traveled by foot, as illustrated in classic novels in which characters walk by fields and woods to nearby villages or far-away cities. In North America, Daniel Boone, Lewis and Clark, and John Muir led the way for many adventurers who explored the frontier. No fences or no trespassing signs blocked their ways. In the twenty-first century, modern transportation removes the need to walk, and restrictive American property laws block walkers from traditional trails and open lands. In the U.S., few places other than national parks, beaches, and long-distance hiking trails remain open for lengthy outdoor wandering. According to Ilgunas, most open land should be ours to traverse. He describes the benefits of responsible, open access to land, citing examples of more liberal laws and traditions in European countries and prescribing rules and regulations to reassure land owners. Outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy this book.--Roche, Rick Copyright 2018 Booklist
Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Woody Guthrie was singing a truth that we've allowed to sicken and nearly die; it's time to nurse it back to health.An assiduous roamer and backcountry ranger, Ilgunas (Trespassing Across America: One Man's Epic, Never-Done-Before (and Sort of Illegal) Hike Across the Heartland, 2016, etc.) returns with a heavily researched, passionate argument about the need for America to emulate many other countries and allow its citizens to roam across the land, public as well as private. He asserts that roaming was long a part of the American way of life, but we have lost the way. He offers some disturbing statistical evidencee.g., how few people own most of the private land and how our national parks and monuments are overflowing with visitors. He also notes how our sedentary lifestyle is affecting our healthand our national budgetand he continually reminds us how much better it is elsewhere for roamers; Scotland and Sweden are among his most frequent examples. Ilgunas populates the text with iconic literary and cultural figures who believed in roaming, from Plato to Rousseau to Thoreau. The author also knows the counterarguments to "free roaming"e.g., lawsuits against landowners, litter, armed roamersand he devotes a significant section of the narrative to answering, if not refuting, them all. In a final chapter devoted to how we might accomplish his dream, the author cites the works and words of legal authorities, and he appeals to our better selvesan approach that, unfortunately, does not often bear fruit. "Let's not be so fixated on something as small as individual liberty," he writes, "when we should be thinking about something far grander and far nobler: the health of the community, the health of the planet, the prosperity of the human race and all our fellow species."Earnest, thoughtful, and alarming in placesan optimistic work that urges America toward a profound cultural shift. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
